Abortion and the Rise of the Christian Right

- NOTOC**

Abortion and the Rise of the Christian Right

Abortion became one of the defining political issues of the modern American Christian Right, but the relationship developed gradually. Conservative evangelical political activism had roots extending well before the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision, including opposition to secularization, communism, changes in sexual morality, restrictions on school prayer, feminism, and other cultural developments. By the late 1970s and early 1980s, however, opposition to abortion had become one of the most effective causes for bringing conservative Protestants, Catholics, and other religious conservatives into a durable political coalition.^[1]

The history does not support a simple account in which American evangelicals uniformly opposed abortion and then entered politics immediately after Roe. Christian denominations differed significantly over abortion, and evangelical attitudes themselves changed over time. Catholics provided much of the institutional leadership of the organized anti-abortion movement before Roe, while Protestant responses ranged from support for abortion-law reform to strong opposition. Some fundamentalists and independent Baptists opposed abortion before 1973, while other evangelical institutions accepted limited legal abortion under particular circumstances.^[2]

Abortion Politics Before Roe v. Wade

The organized anti-abortion movement did not begin with the Christian Right. Catholic organizations were particularly important in developing anti-abortion institutions during the 1960s and early 1970s. The National Right to Life Committee emerged from Catholic organizing but gradually developed into a broader movement that included people from multiple religious traditions.

At the same time, American Protestant opinion was far from uniform. Liberal Protestant organizations often supported loosening abortion restrictions, while conservative Protestants expressed varying levels of concern about abortion. Some evangelical and fundamentalist ministers opposed abortion before Roe, but abortion had not yet become the defining political marker of conservative evangelical identity that it would later become.

Southern Baptist Convention resolutions illustrate this transitional period particularly clearly. A 1971 resolution affirmed the value of fetal life while supporting the possibility of legal abortion in cases including rape, incest, severe fetal deformity, and threats to a woman's physical or mental health.^[3] In 1974 the convention explicitly reaffirmed that earlier position, describing it as a middle ground between unrestricted abortion and treating all abortion as murder.^[4]

These documents demonstrate that evangelical institutions did not move immediately or uniformly into the position that later characterized much of the Christian Right.

Roe v. Wade and Evangelical Responses

The Supreme Court's 1973 decision in Roe v. Wade transformed the legal framework surrounding abortion, but evangelical political mobilization remained gradual. During the middle of the 1970s, conservative Protestants increasingly discussed abortion within a broader set of concerns involving sexual morality, feminism, family authority, religious education, and the perceived secularization of American society.

Southern Baptist resolutions again illustrate the process. The denomination's 1976 resolution condemned indiscriminate abortion and affirmed the sanctity of fetal life, while continuing to emphasize a limited governmental role and access to medical services and counseling. The 1977 and 1979 resolutions strengthened opposition to "abortion on demand" while retaining portions of this earlier language.^[5]^[6]

By 1980 the convention had adopted a substantially stronger political position, supporting legislation or a constitutional amendment prohibiting abortion except when necessary to save the mother's life.^[7]

The evolution of these resolutions reflects the broader transformation occurring within conservative evangelical politics.

Francis Schaeffer and Evangelical Anti-Abortion Activism

Theologian Francis Schaeffer became an influential figure in persuading conservative evangelicals to view abortion as part of a larger struggle over Western civilization, Christianity, and the value of human life. Schaeffer and surgeon C. Everett Koop's 1979 project Whatever Happened to the Human Race? connected abortion with euthanasia, infanticide, and what they described as declining respect for human life.^[8]

Films, lectures, books, churches, and evangelical media helped circulate these arguments. Anti-abortion activism therefore spread through religious networks as well as through conventional political organizations. The process helped transform abortion from an issue many evangelicals had previously regarded as primarily Catholic into a major concern of conservative Protestant politics.

Abortion, Feminism, and the Family-Values Coalition

Abortion did not develop as an isolated political issue. During the 1970s, it increasingly intersected with disputes involving the Equal Rights Amendment, feminism, contraception, sex education, homosexuality, parental authority, school prayer, and changing gender roles.

Activists such as Phyllis Schlafly mobilized opposition to the Equal Rights Amendment and presented feminism and changing family structures as threats to traditional social arrangements. Conservative evangelical women's organizations, including groups associated with Beverly LaHaye, later brought abortion into a broader "family values" agenda.

This combination proved politically important because people motivated by different concerns could participate in the same organizations. One activist might have entered conservative politics primarily because of abortion, another because of the ERA, religious schools, sexual morality, or school prayer. These constituencies increasingly operated within the same political network.

Race, Segregation, and Competing Explanations

Historians disagree over the relative importance of abortion in the initial formation of the Religious Right. One influential interpretation, associated particularly with historian Randall Balmer, argues that federal challenges to the tax-exempt status of racially segregated Christian schools helped motivate conservative evangelical leaders to organize politically before abortion became their most effective public rallying issue.^[9]

Other historians caution against interpreting abortion merely as a replacement issue for segregation. Evidence shows that some evangelicals and fundamentalists opposed abortion well before the creation of the Moral Majority, and grassroots anti-abortion activism was developing independently of the political strategies of national Religious Right leaders. This interpretation emphasizes that abortion, school desegregation, feminism, the ERA, sexuality, religious education, and other conflicts overlapped rather than following a single sequence of cause and effect.^[10]

The available scholarship therefore suggests that the Christian Right emerged from several intersecting political and religious developments. Abortion eventually became exceptionally important, but it operated within a broader conservative reaction to cultural and institutional change.

Jerry Falwell and the Moral Majority

Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority, founded in 1979, became one of the most visible organizations of the emerging Christian Right. Falwell and allied activists sought to persuade evangelical pastors and church members who had previously avoided direct political activity to participate in elections and public-policy campaigns.

Abortion was part of a broader Moral Majority agenda that included school prayer, pornography, homosexuality, religious education, and traditional family structures. Christian Voice and other organizations pursued similar strategies, attempting to transform evangelical congregations, broadcasting networks, mailing lists, and religious institutions into an organized political constituency.

Contemporary reporting from 1979 already described efforts to unite evangelicals, fundamentalists, conservative Catholics, and Mormons around abortion and other social issues.^[11]

The Republican Party and the 1980 Election

The political significance of abortion increased as the Republican and Democratic parties gradually adopted more distinct positions on the issue.

The 1976 Republican platform illustrates that this realignment was not yet complete. It explicitly acknowledged substantial disagreement within the party over abortion while supporting efforts by those seeking a constitutional amendment protecting fetal life.^[12]

Four years later, the Republican platform went considerably further. The 1980 platform endorsed a constitutional amendment to protect unborn life and supported restrictions on taxpayer funding for abortion.^[13]

Ronald Reagan's presidential campaign provided conservative evangelical leaders with a candidate around whom they could organize despite disagreements between religious conservatives and the Republican Party on other subjects. Reagan publicly adopted anti-abortion positions, supported school prayer, and cultivated relationships with figures including Falwell.

The 1980 election consequently became an important stage in the consolidation of the relationship between conservative evangelical activism and Republican electoral politics.

Institutionalizing the Christian Right

The political infrastructure created during the late 1970s survived the Moral Majority itself. James Dobson's Focus on the Family, Beverly LaHaye's Concerned Women for America, Pat Robertson's political organizations, the Christian Coalition, anti-abortion organizations, legal advocacy groups, churches, radio and television ministries, and direct-mail networks continued organizing conservative Christian voters.

The anti-abortion movement simultaneously developed increasingly sophisticated electoral, legislative, fundraising, and legal strategies. Activists worked to influence party platforms, congressional races, state legislatures, presidential nominations, and judicial appointments.

The Christian Coalition under Pat Robertson and Ralph Reed continued many of these strategies during the 1990s. By then, opposition to abortion had become deeply embedded within Republican national politics, while the Democratic Party had moved more firmly toward defending legal abortion.

Courts and the Long Campaign Against Roe

When attempts to enact a constitutional amendment prohibiting abortion failed, conservative activists increasingly focused on changing the federal judiciary. Presidential elections became important not only because of legislation but because presidents nominate federal judges and Supreme Court justices.

Anti-abortion organizations and conservative legal networks pursued incremental restrictions on abortion while supporting judicial nominees considered more receptive to challenges to Roe. This legal strategy developed over several decades rather than through a single organization or election.

The connection between abortion politics and judicial nominations eventually became one of the most durable elements of the alliance between conservative Christians and the Republican Party. The Supreme Court's 2022 decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, which overturned the federal constitutional abortion right recognized under Roe, represented the culmination of one important objective pursued by the anti-abortion legal and political movement for decades.

Religious Diversity and Opposition to the Christian Right

Although the Christian Right often presented opposition to abortion in explicitly religious terms, American religious opinion remained diverse throughout this history.

Catholics themselves disagreed over abortion politics, and organizations of Protestants, Jews, Catholics, and other religious Americans supported abortion rights. Liberal Protestant denominations frequently took positions very different from conservative evangelical organizations.

This diversity is important because the political rise of anti-abortion Christianity should not be confused with a universal Christian position. The historical record includes anti-abortion Democrats, abortion-rights Republicans, conservative Catholics, liberal Catholics, evangelical opponents of abortion, evangelical supporters of limited abortion access, and religious organizations defending abortion rights.^[14]

Abortion and the Modern Christian Right

Over time, abortion became more than a discrete policy question within conservative evangelical politics. It became intertwined with partisan identity, religious identity, ideas about family and sexuality, judicial politics, and debates over the proper relationship between Christianity and American public life.

The political coalition built during the 1970s and 1980s also outlived the institutions that first created it. The Moral Majority dissolved, but organizations such as the Christian Coalition, Focus on the Family, anti-abortion advocacy organizations, churches, legal groups, and Republican political networks continued developing the infrastructure of conservative Christian activism.

Research included in the source material indicates that opposition to abortion remains especially strong among white evangelical Protestants and continues to correlate with Republican identification and, in some studies, Christian-nationalist beliefs. The contemporary relationship between religion and abortion politics is therefore partly a legacy of political alignments developed during the late twentieth century.

Conclusion

Abortion played a major role in the rise of the modern Christian Right, but it was neither the movement's sole origin nor an issue that produced immediate evangelical unity after Roe v. Wade. Conservative evangelical political activism had deeper roots, while the early anti-abortion movement depended heavily on Catholic organization. Evangelical attitudes themselves ranged considerably before becoming more consistently opposed to legal abortion.

During the 1970s, abortion became intertwined with conflicts over feminism, the Equal Rights Amendment, sexuality, education, race, religious schools, parental authority, and secularization. Leaders including Francis Schaeffer and Jerry Falwell helped make abortion an increasingly important evangelical cause, while organizations such as the Moral Majority transformed religious concerns into electoral organization.

The Republican Party's movement from substantial internal disagreement over abortion in 1976 to explicit support for a constitutional anti-abortion amendment in 1980 illustrates the speed of the developing political alignment. During the Reagan era and afterward, abortion became institutionalized within conservative Christian and Republican politics through advocacy organizations, electoral mobilization, legislative campaigns, and a long-term focus on the federal judiciary.

The resulting coalition reshaped American politics. Its history is best understood not as the product of one event or one motivation, but as the convergence of religious conviction, grassroots activism, cultural conflict, organizational strategy, party realignment, and legal campaigning over several decades.

- TOC**